"Smell That Sadness? Female Tears Turn Off Men"

STEVE INSKEEP, Host:

When a woman at the movies starts crying, it may be having an effect on her male companion. That may not surprise many guys out there, but this could. It may affect her male companion even if he can't see the tears. That's the conclusion of a team of Israeli scientists. NPR's Joe Palca has more.

JOE PALCA: You don't have to be a psychologist to know that tears can have a powerful effect. You see someone cry, and anger tends to turn to compassion. But a group of Israeli scientists wondered if the effect was strictly visual. In other words, might there be some chemical in human tears that was responsible for that urge to care for someone? So they advertised for males or females willing to donate tears.

IDAN FRUMIN: We got, mainly, female donors.

PALCA: Idan Frumin is a biochemist at the Weizmann Institute for Science in Rehovot. He and his colleagues decided to see whether just smelling a woman's tears had a measurable effect on men. So they had their female tear donors watch sad movies, then they took a few drops of a woman's tears, and had men sniff them to see if the tears had any recognizable smell.

INSKEEP: And they don't.

PALCA: Even though they didn't smell anything, Frumin and his colleagues still asked their subjects to fill out a questionnaire.

INSKEEP: One of the questions in the questionnaire was: What is the state of sexual arousal of this specific subject in this specific moment? And to our amazement, we saw that - a drop in arousal.

PALCA: Thomas Cleland is a psychologist at Cornell University.

THOMAS CLELAND: It's probably the best study yet showing that chemical communication between humans is a reality.

PALCA: But psychologist James Cherry, of Boston University, says while the Israeli study convinces him that there is some chemical signal, you can't say it's only in tears from the Israeli experiments.

INSKEEP: Certainly, there are effects. But whatever substance, or substances, that may be there could be found in a lot of places. You just don't know that.

PALCA: Psychologist Ad Vingerhoets, of Tilburg University in the Netherlands, has also been studying human tears. He says women's tears may reduce male testosterone and sexual arousal, but that's not the main effect.

INSKEEP: It's my hypothesis that tears - has an effect not primarily on testosterone, but on oxytocin.

PALCA: Joe Palca, NPR News, Washington.